Comparing Celtic FC Greatest XI v Rangers FC Greatest XI Of All Time
RW- Davie Wilson
Wilson was a key figure in the club’s early 1960s success, showcasing a natural striker’s instinct that made him a significant threat in front of goal. With an impressive record of 157 goals in 373 appearances, he delivered exceptional performances as a winger.
One of Wilson’s standout qualities was his ability to slip unnoticed into the box, capitalizing on crosses from teammates like Alex Scott and Willie Henderson. Although primarily right-footed, he skillfully dribbled with both feet, effectively crossing from the left and cutting inside for powerful shots. His tactical versatility contributed to his remarkable goal-scoring tally, especially for a player not primarily positioned as a striker.
LW – Davie Cooper
The Scottish left-winger made 377 appearances for Rangers during his 12-year tenure in Glasgow, with his stunning goal against Celtic in the 1979 Dryburgh Cup Final often hailed as one of the greatest goals ever scored.
Walter Smith, a former manager of Rangers, praised Cooper’s exceptional talent, stating, “God gave Davie Cooper a talent. He would not be disappointed with how it was used.” Throughout his career, Cooper secured three Scottish Premier Division titles, three Scottish Cups, and seven Scottish League Cups.
ST- Ally McCoist
Super Ally is undeniably one of Scotland’s greatest strikers, boasting an impressive goal ratio of over one goal every two games. McCoist began his career at St. Johnstone before moving to Sunderland in 1981, returning to Scotland two years later to join Rangers. His time at Rangers was remarkable, making him the club’s all-time leading goalscorer and contributing to nine consecutive league titles from 1988–89 to 1996–97.
He holds records for the most league and European goals for Rangers and was the first Scottish player to win and retain the Golden Boot. McCoist led the club in scoring for nine of his 15 seasons and was a key player during the Nine-In-A-Row triumphs alongside Richard Gough and Ian Ferguson. His 15-year tenure with Rangers set a benchmark in striking records that is unlikely to be surpassed.
Who do you think has the better team and why? Let us know in the comments below.